Energy Direct Debit Reasonableness Calculator

    Enter the figures from your latest energy statement. This tool compares twelve months of your direct debit against your estimated annual energy cost, then takes account of your balance, the time of year and whether your readings are actual or estimated.

    Pre-filled from your saved My PowerGuardian details: annual electricity use, annual gas use. Every value can be changed below.

    Your energy details

    Your payments and balance

    Only used to address the letter you can generate below. Leave blank for a general letter.

    How the calculation works

    • Annual electricity cost = annual electricity kWh × unit rate + 365 × standing charge
    • Annual gas cost = annual gas kWh × unit rate + 365 × standing charge
    • Pence figures are divided by 100 to give pounds
    • Average monthly cost = estimated annual cost ÷ 12
    • Annual payments = current monthly direct debit × 12
    • A debit balance is added to the expected annual collection before the payment is judged, so repaying arrears is not mistaken for overpaying

    Related guidance

    The PowerGuardian Home Energy Record

    A free printable workbook for logging monthly meter readings, bills, Direct Debit payments and account balances in one place — so you can check bills against real readings and evidence a billing dispute if one arises.

    PDF workbook · PowerGuardian · free, no email required

    Download the free guide

    Frequently asked questions

    Explore this topic

    Energy bills and the price cap

    Read the UK energy bills and price cap guide for the full picture.

    Related guides

    PowerGuardian research

    Continue Saving Money

    Free calculators picked for this topic.

    Energy Bill Calculator

    Enter your kWh usage, unit rate and standing charge for daily, monthly and annual totals.

    Open Calculator

    Standing Charge Calculator

    What the daily standing charge costs you over a month and a year, gas and electricity.

    Open Calculator

    Should I Switch Energy Supplier?

    Is switching worth it right now? A decision framework using the current cap and fixed-deal evidence.

    Open Calculator

    Compare Energy Suppliers

    Independent PowerGuardian scores out of 100 for relevant suppliers, as at 21 September 2026.

    British Gas

    55/100

    The UK's largest supplier remains financially rock-solid but service and complaint metrics continue to lag the market, with smart-meter billing delays a recurring theme.

    Compare Supplier

    EDF Energy

    73/100

    EDF is a steady, financially robust supplier with mid-table service and fair fixed-tariff renewals. Few surprises in either direction.

    Compare Supplier

    Octopus Energy

    92/100

    Octopus continues to lead the UK market on customer service and complaint handling, backed by genuinely competitive smart tariffs and strong financial backing. The clear front-runner on our intelligence dashboard.

    Compare Supplier

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Quick answers to the questions people ask most about this topic.

    Free PowerGuardian Report

    Standing Charges Report

    A deep dive into the daily fixed fees on every UK bill — regional differences, drivers and the case for reform.

    Save This Advice

    Create your free personalised dashboard to keep track of useful guides, calculators and savings opportunities.

    Create My PowerGuardian